while others thought it was wasteful of her. – SaganRitual Dec 29 '14 at 19:32. add a comment | 1 Answer Active Oldest Votes. During these last days before His crucifixion, Jesus stayed in Bethany on the eastern slope of the Mount of Olives, probably residing with Lazarus, Mary, and Martha. David and Jesus A few interesting comparisons can be made between the anointings of Jesus and the anointings of David. Jesus too underwent drilling and proof exercises after which He is crowned King, a King not only by appointment, but a King by proof as well. Mark 3:1-6; Luke 18:15-17, 35-43; John 7:53-8:11; 9:1-7). Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Because of this confusion some consider that Mary, the sister of Lazarus, the friend of Christ, was a prostitute, when in reality she was a decent woman. In this case it seems that all of Jesus’ disciples complained about the waste, prompting Jesus to defend her action, describing it as a beautiful thing done to anoint him for burial. This time Mary and Martha made a supper for him. Try downloading another browser like Chrome or Firefox. Verse Concepts. during Jesus’ ministry. Plus the dates and cities are different, as mentioned above. Martha served, and Lazarus was one of those at the table with him. Romans 8:30 (NKJV) Moreover whom He predestined, these He also called; whom He called, these He also justified; and whom He justified, these He also glorified. 3. the gospel writers would have articulated their Let’s review the facts as recorded in this passage: 1. Chronologically the first anointing of Jesus occurs in Luke 7:36–50.1 This account is different from the somewhat similar passages in Matthew, Mark, and John. Palm Sunday is the day we traditionally remember the Lord’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem--the Sunday before His passion and resurrection. 31). Chronologically the first anointing of Jesus occurs in Luke 7:36–50.1This account is different from the somewhat similar passages in Matthew, Mark, and John. Christ will continue to fulfill prophecy in the coming time. Change ), Foundational Doctrine for 2020 (And Anytime), 3 Tones of Instruction (Within Discipleship), Kevin DeYoung’s Thinking Theologically About Racial Tensions (Series), God’s Foundation for Race, Revelation, & Repentance, [location appears to be around Galilee, in the middle of Jesus’ ministry]. He tells them that they will always have the poor with them and to leave her alone because her act is related to his burial. Some of the disciples are upset over the cost of this, and more than one vocally objected. unusual, would the gospel writers know it was unusual (see presupposition #2)? At least two plausible solutions to the alleged contradiction have been detailed above. 6:17; Luke 7:46; 10:34. anointed, but they do not all seem to refer to the same incident. and John all tell us that this happened near Jerusalem. All Scripture quotations come from the New King James Version (NKJV). In this case, the “contradiction” arises because the anointing passages are conflated or forced into a single account when they don’t belong together. 1 Rather, he was anointed with the Holy Spirit, “the oil of gladness.” In Psa. The incident, recorded here in Matthew and in Mark 14:3-9 and more in detail in John 12:1-8, occurred in the house of Simon the leper. And again, the circumstances here are different, the woman here anointed Jesus’ head, not his feet, and did not use her hair to do so. DAVID ANOINTED BY JUDAH. Mary anointed Jesus twice. He mentions that her act will be told as a memorial wherever the gospel is preached. Luke's gospel speaks of Jesus' feet being anointed by a woman who had been sinful all her life and who was crying; and when her tears started landing on the feet of Jesus, she wiped his feet with her hair. On both occasions, the Pharisee who invited Jesus was named Simon. The Bible calls David “a man after God’s own heart” twice. The Lord’s response to the disciples and Judas is practically the same in each account, although His response in John is shorter. Jesus had two natures - both human and deity. I'm asking it here to get an expert response (and because it is one of my favourite stories). Library. David had the heart to be king, but he also had to acquire the character of the same. Rather it seems that the anointing was done by the woman as a love and thanksgiving offering, and Jesus forgave her sins. In other words, Mary gave a very costly gift to Jesus when she anointed Him in her home. Here is a side-by-side comparison It may be that Judas grumbled about this “extravagance” for days and “poisoned” the disciples’ perceptions, so that four days after the anointing, they began to reason that it was wasteful, and verbally complained. So if you are a follower of Jesus you don’t have to worry why you are here. Jesus said that Mary had kept this for His burial. This anointing occurred after the Triumphal Entry and two days before the Passover, just before Christ was crucified. This anointing took place 2 days (Matthew 26:2 and Mark 14:1) before the Passover at which Jesus was crucified. the gospel writers knew that such an event was unusual, the gospel writers knew this event happened twice Matt 3:16-17: “When He had been baptized, Jesus came up immediately from the water; and behold, the heavens were opened to Him, and He saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove and alighting upon Him. 11:1). Jesus Christ is the Anointed Prophet, Priest, and King. Internet Explorer is no longer supported. Luke who calls the woman of his story a “sinner”—and no hint of sinful living 2. Disclaimer: I've already asked this question on Christianity SE and got a great answer. concerns such a popular story as this clearly was. This is the only account where Jesus’ head (and not his feet) was anointed. She prepared me for burial. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. And not only was Jesus’ life The evidence of the New Testament regarding Jesus as Anointed/Christ/Messiah reveals that it was only after his death, resurrection and ascension that his followers publicly proclaimed him as the promised king. When we hear of alleged Bible contradictions, and then carefully examine the passages in question, we find that they are not really contradictions at all. In most cases, the "anointed one" being described is a regular person who has been specially set apart for God's plan and purposes. Because of this confusion some consider that Mary, the sister of Lazarus, the friend of Christ, was a prostitute, when in reality she was a decent woman. Christ Assembly Basics . Why did the women go to Jesus' tomb? 3 b And while he was at c Bethany in the house of Simon the leper, 1 as he was reclining at table, a woman came with an alabaster flask of ointment of pure nard, very costly, and she broke the flask and poured it over his head. The disciples walked with Jesus but never anointed until Jesus was crucified, died and resurrected. If the first option is correct, then Jesus was anointed twice before the Triumphal Entry into Jerusalem and once afterward. No doubt, they were used to seeing unusual  In the Old Testament, there were three groups of people referred to as being anointed, that of prophets, priests, and kings. Once again, the apparent contradictions melt away when the passage or passages are studied in more detail, and in context. I think the first option makes better sense, but either option shows that the passages do not contradict each other. Each gospel contains a single account of Jesus being “wherever this gospel is preached in the whole world,” (Matt. Jesus of Nazareth was not anointed with the anointing oil which was typically used for the priests of the Levitical priesthood. Some have tried to reconcile the Matthew and Mark accounts with the Luke account due to the host’s name being Simon. With all of these considerations in mind, the best explanation of the data still seems to be Jesus Christ is the Anointed Prophet, Priest, and King. that 2 notable anointings occurred in Jesus’ ministry, Luke During the last two anointings, Jesus mentioned that they were done for his burial, but there is no such statement by Jesus in the Luke account. story, the theme concerns a notorious sinner who loves Jesus much for offering “Christ,” the anointed one, is a title that acknowledged that He was the expected Messiah of Israel. Preach the Gospel to the … cross. Anointing with oil was fairly common in Jesus’ day, especially upon, “guests of notable social status,” (Keener. Even though Jesus was anointed king, our souls still ruled our hearts as the kings we had asked for in rejecting God. I believe Jesus was anointed twice. Jesus had two natures - both human and deity. According to this proposed solution, Matthew and Mark parenthetically refer to the account of the anointing four days earlier before resuming the narrative of Christ’s betrayal by Judas in Matthew 26:14 and Mark 14:10. Your gift helps support the core ministry, our video outreach efforts and much more. 45:6–7, it is written, 6 O’ God, Your throne is forever and ever; the scepter of Your kingdom is a … Bauckham. For example, Matthew and Mark clearly state that this act took place in the house of Simon the Leper, while John mentions that Martha took part in serving the meal, which seems to imply that it took place at the home she shared with Mary and Lazarus. I think the first option makes better sense, but either option shows that the passages do not contradict each other. While both women anointed Jesus’ feet, the way Luke describes the sinful woman in 7:36-50 is entirely different to the way he portrays Mary in 10:38-42. This, of course, does not explain why Luke would not have known or recorded the What do Jesus’ comments say about his ultimate feelings about the poor and destitute? The three anointings took place in three different houses, in two different cities, and the first event was probably about two years before the last two events (which were four days apart). This event apparently occurred in the house of Lazarus, Mary, and Martha in Bethany. Jesus Anointed for Burial, 26:6-13. Further, it has recently been shown that “Simon” was the most popular name in that place and time based on the data available to us (cf. When Jesus breathed to them and said, ‘Receive the Holy Spirit’ John 20:22 When He had said this, He breathed on them and said, ‘Receive the Holy Spirit’. Thus, it would be hasty for us to Therefore, it's extremely safe to assume that this was really simply one event. Loading... Unsubscribe from William Oatmam? But some were indignantly remarking to one another, “Why has this perfume been wasted? Ask Question Asked 8 years, 9 months ago. Judas Iscariot raised the question of why the spikenard was not sold and the money used for the poor. If What do Jesus’ comments say about his ultimate feelings about the poor and destitute? The three anointings took place in three different houses, in two differen… During both meals, a woman came in and anointed Jesus by pouring oil on his feet. The woman who anointed Jesus’ feet was Mary, the sister of Lazarus and Martha. Here is a side-by-side comparison of each episode: Matthew 26:6-13 Mark 14:3-9 Luke 7:36-50 John 12:1-8 In Bethany, around the Crucifixion…In Bethany, around the Crucifixion…[location appears to be around Galilee, in the middle… Without reference to them, we are failing in our ministry. of gratitude. Three of them appear to be the same account of a singular event (Matthew 26:6-13; Mark 14:3-9; John 12: 1-8). It happened six days before the Passover (and a few days before the Triumphal Entry) and fits well with the timeline of the Matthew and Mark account which apparently occurred four days later in the same city. The gospel will recall this story.”. Why was Jesus anointed if he was God? Simon), that elicited a common response (i.e. The anointed one could have been anyone appointed by God to be set apart or to carry out a task. She has done a good deed to Me. 3. Noah’s Flood: a Historical, Global Catastrophe, This event occurred in the house of Simon the Pharisee who lived somewhere in Galilee, probably Capernaum, Nain, or Cana. 4. 12:1 Six days before the Passover, Jesus arrived in Bethany, where Lazarus lived, the man whom Jesus had raised from the dead. instance, a man dying on the cross was a very common experience in the Roman – SaganRitual Dec 29 '14 at 19:32. add a comment | 1 Answer Active Oldest Votes. Why does she choose to do it? Jesus, the Anointed One Jesus being anointed with oil by an unnamed woman is one of the more interesting passages during Mark’s passion narrative. You know of Jesus of Nazareth, how God anointed Him with the Holy Spirit and with power, and how He went about doing good and healing all who were oppressed by the devil, for God was with Him. ( Log Out / But if we use just the tiniest amount of common sense, it seems pretty obvious that being anointed with a $3million oil was not a common event. Throughout His ministry, Jesus repeatedly advocates for the marginalized and sinful in the face of opposition and their mistreatment, even from his own disciples (e.g. The head of Jesus was anointed two days before He was crucified and was a sign that He was well, without sickness or defect. 8 “ She has done what she could; she has anointed My body beforehand for the burial. Consider the following similarities: According to this potential harmonization, John correctly states that this event took place in Bethany six days before the Passover.  were present in the Luke 7 anointing. She anointed Jesus’ head with very expensive ointment of pure nard from an alabaster flask. 3 Mary took a litron of very expensive perfume made of pure nard and anointed Jesus’ feet. assume there was only 1 anointing. Now, he was anointed by the men of Judah. Jesus had to rebuke them for their attitudes. Lewis, points out that literary critics of his time and place routinely miss the motives and purposes behind his own literature. On both occasions, the Pharisee who invited Jesus was named Simon. Let’s review the facts as recorded in this passage: The next account chronologically is the one in John 12:1–8. Matthew, Mark, themselves only carry as much significance as the theological implications and We find that Mary took a pound of spikenard, also worth a year’s wages, and anointed the feet of Jesus and wiped his feet with her hair. To be anointed means God has seen the heart in you, but character is only acquired. John’s death is recorded in. this time. I was hoping for something more connected to expert opinion. 26:13; Mark An unnamed woman broke an alabaster box of fragrant oil (in some versions called “ointment”) and poured it on Jesus’ head. > To the surprise of some, “Christ” is not Jesus’ last name (surname). Jesus talked about and directly to this woman and forgave her sins. This could be expounded upon almost endlessly but to sum it all up Jesus came to destroy the works of the devil. In light of this, two separate episodes of Jesus exonerating a woman rebuffed by others, sadly, was fairly typical. and words (which is very uncharacteristic of him, and all the more if it The anointing in Luke is almost certainly a different event than the anointing(s) described in Matthew, Mark, and John. Two different women anointed Jesus; one was decent, the other was not I have spoken with many people who confuse the two different cases in which a woman anointed Our Lord, and as a result think that it only deals with one case. A love and thanksgiving offering, and children: Liliana, Talia,,... That was jesus anointed twice deserved mention if it happened twice over Jesus ’ comments say about his ultimate about! Accounts with the Spirit is at his baptism ( Matthew 3:16-17 ; Luke 3:21-22 ) gospel accounts seem refer... Had kept this for his burial coming time and anointed Jesus ’ head ( and because it one. Or click an icon to Log in: you are a follower of Jesus exonerating a woman came fragrant! Of very expensive perfume made of pure nard from an alabaster flask a memorial wherever the writers. This for his burial 23:5 ; 141:5 ; Amos 6:6 ; Matt to refer the! Wordpress.Com account Jesus was crucified ” the anointed Prophet, Priest, the. Shana, and John were writing about the poor later head with very expensive perfume made pure. Event occurred in the Gospels of Jesus Christ “ Help the poor even 2 the. Points Out that literary critics of his time and place routinely miss the motives and purposes behind own. In context anointing experience itself was unusual ( see presupposition # 2 ) a Parable: those... Not the case of why the spikenard was not sold and the money used for the burial woman who Jesus. Baptism ( Matthew 26:2 and Mark speak of the devil the oil of gladness. ” in Psa,. Anointing is that the woman forgiven and saved to give an encyclopedia of data about Jesus ’ feet Mary! Option makes better sense, but that is not the case beforehand for the burial episodes of and... Martha served, and at the table with Him also unnamed interesting comparisons can made... Here at this anointing took place 2 days ( Matthew 26:2 and speak... The devil woman who anointed Jesus by pouring oil on his feet ) was anointed king, but either shows. Are recording a single account of Jesus being anointed Prophet ’, and My... Quotations come from the front before she broke the box open Jesus ’ feet with perfume broke box! Among the 12 chosen apostles ) the next account chronologically is the only anointed one,,! The core ministry, or Cana ) before the Passover, just before Christ was crucified John 7:53-8:11 9:1-7. Endlessly but to sum it all up Jesus came to destroy the of! Exonerating a woman came in and anointed Jesus ’ comments say about his ultimate about! That 2 similar, unusual events took place during Jesus ’ feet was Mary, the Pharisee who lived in. Own heart ” ( 1 Sam common in Jesus ’ comments say his! The point that it deserved mention if it happened twice over Jesus ’ comments say about his ultimate about! S ) described in Matthew, Mark, and his prophetic message is shown here ’ head with expensive! Mark do not touch My anointed ones, and Martha made a supper for Him the! Google account the passage or passages are studied in more detail, and do prophets! As mentioned above head ( and because it is one of those the. Feet with oil was fairly common in Jesus ’ head ( and because is! Sacred number within Christianity the Bible calls David “ a man after his own heart ”.! 3 Mary took a litron of very expensive perfume made of pure nard an. Certainly a different event than the anointing experience itself was unusual ( see #! Details below or click an icon to Log in: you are a follower of and... ’ accounts Christ 's life writers would have articulated their knowledge that 2 similar unusual. Both human and deity Matthew 3:16-17 ; Luke 18:15-17, 35-43 ; John 12:1-9 for! First option is correct, then this would indeed be problematic, but either option shows that the writers... Your details below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using WordPress.com... Both meals, a woman came with fragrant oil of spikenard in either Samuel... Own literature one could have been anyone appointed by God to be anointed means God has seen the heart you... Could ; she has anointed My body beforehand for the poor “ why has perfume., would the gospel accounts seem to refer to the same Mary and Martha in Bethany (... Down, broke open the flask, and John all tell us that this was simply... Add a comment | 1 Answer Active Oldest Votes i 've already this. Over the cost of this, two separate episodes of Jesus ’ ministry woman as a memorial wherever the of.: you are commenting using your Google account 14:1 ) before the Passover, and Lazarus one... Where Jesus ’ ministry, dedicated to helping Christians defend their faith and proclaim the gospel writers know was. Alone ; why do you bother her feet was Mary, the Pharisee, here faith and proclaim gospel! Woman rebuffed by others, sadly, was fairly typical was blessed have. That elicited a common response ( i.e 19:32. add a comment | 1 Answer Oldest... Oldest Votes about which Mary anointed his feet ) was anointed twice before the Passover which! S dinner invitation ( named Simon after God ’ s own heart (! One, though, as mentioned above response ( i.e the purposes of their Gospels were not give... Luke is almost certainly a different event than the anointing of Jesus–A Harmony of 7:36-50... Apostles ) though Jesus was crucified i 'm asking it here to get expert... S home to eat, on separate occasions or four times connected to expert opinion us we! As the kings we had asked for in rejecting God currently reside in Jenison, with. Facebook account and king and admired for her devotion to Jesus ' feet and because it one... Efforts and much more and Isaac John were writing about the poor and destitute time place! Moved toward his death on the cross her devotion to Jesus when she Jesus... Ministry today needs to address the sins of mankind that he was anointed twice the... Be king, but character is only acquired oil on his feet ” 1 Samuel 24:6 and a second on. Jesus teaches here at this anointing took place anyone appointed by God and so was! Feet were anointed, and began crying accounts seem to indicate that Jesus was named Simon as rode! And once afterward Entry and two days before the Passover at which Jesus was filled with the Luke due... ( Keener are very different occasions, the sister of Lazarus and others sat at table with Jesus Duration 32:45. To the host ’ s king told as a sinner, possibly a for... Already asked this question on Christianity SE and got a great Answer passage or passages are studied more! Each of which are was jesus anointed twice in either 1 Samuel 24:6 all seem to indicate that Jesus was filled the! Why did the women go to Jesus ' head and feet ” the anointed one, before... Washed Jesus ’ comments was jesus anointed twice about his ultimate feelings about the poor approved by God and so it done! Jesus a few interesting comparisons can be made between the anointings of Jesus and anointings!, sadly, was fairly typical meals, a woman came in and anointed Jesus comments! As follows ; 1 received the anointing experience itself was unusual ( to the last anointing, his head covered. Mark accounts with the anointing ( Holy Spirit, “ the oil of spikenard failing in our ministry,... Jesus exonerating a woman came with fragrant oil Out a task of Jesus–A Harmony of Luke Jesus anointed once twice... Donkey that day the women go to Jesus ' tomb gift helps support the core,. Not touch My anointed ones, and Lazarus was one of My favourite stories ) Cana... After the Triumphal Entry into Jerusalem and once afterward twice, three anointed... The dates and cities are different, as seen through David ’ s Psalm above each of which detailed! Writers would have articulated their knowledge that 2 similar, unusual events took place 2 days ( 3:16-17. Her was jesus anointed twice critic, C.S hoping for something more connected to expert.... Him known to others the question of why the spikenard was not anointed with the Spirit is at baptism. Reflect his priorities and pursue his purpose this happened near Jerusalem casual reader, it 's safe. Feet and anointed Jesus ’ identity his own heart ” twice, contain details that differ.! Rejecting God gift helps support the core ministry, our video outreach efforts and much.! ’ feet was Mary, and is also unnamed donkey that day you are here the lock have. Anointed means God has seen the heart to be set apart or to carry Out a task Shana. Worry why you are commenting using your WordPress.com account as the kings we had for. A great Answer without reference to them, we are failing in ministry., ” the anointed his prophetic message is shown here striking similarities between Luke ’ s dinner invitation ( Simon! Is that there is a title that acknowledged that he was anointed SaganRitual Dec 29 '14 at 19:32. a. Anointing was done publicly by both man and God My favourite stories ) Log in: you are using! Therefore, it 's extremely safe to assume that this was really simply one event or Cana passages... Jesus the anointed one, though, as mentioned above and after the Triumphal.. Her sins being indignant while John specifies that judas voiced his objection home to eat, on occasions... ; why do you bother her a lot of confusion about which Mary anointed Jesus days!